- 1973 Oliver
- 1974 Fiddler on the Roof
- 1975 Man of La Mancha
- 1976 Mame
- 1977 My Fair Lady
- 1978 The Sound of Music
- 1980 Man of La Mancha
- 1981 The King and I
- 1982 Oliver
- 1983 Oklahoma
- 1985 My Fair Lady
- 1986 Fiddler on the Roof
- 1987 Anne of Green Gables
- 1988 The Sound of Music
- 1990 The Wizard of Oz
- 1991 Finian’s Rainbow
- 1992 Anything Goes
- 1993 Annie
- 1994 Anne of Green Gables
- 1995 The King and I
- 1996 The Music Man
- 1997 Oklahoma
- 1998 The Wizard of Oz
- 1999 My Fair Lady
- 2000 Oliver
- 2001 Annie
- 2002 Anne of Green Gables
- 2003 The Music Man
- 2004 The Sound of Music
- 2005 The Wizard of Oz
- 2006 Bye Bye Birdie
- 2007 Hello, Dolly
- 2008 Annie
- 2009 Anne of Green Gables
- 2010 The Sound of Music
- 2011 Fiddler on the Roof
- 2012 Wizard of Oz
- 2013 Oliver!
- 2014 Beauty and the Beast
- 2015 The Sound of Music
- 2016 Honk!
- 2017 Cinderella
- 2018 The Wizard of Oz
- 2019 Anne of Green Gables
- 2021 Frozen Jr.
- 2022 Sister Act Jr.
- 2023 Alice in Wonderland
- 2024 Shrek The Musical
